Are Granny Flats in Ontario an Asset or Liability When Selling a Home?
In Ontario, the rise of housing costs and stricter mortgage qualification rules have pushed many homeowners and buyers to rethink traditional home setups.
One increasingly relevant option is the granny flat or secondary suite—a self-contained apartment within a single-family home. These spaces typically include a kitchen, bathroom, separate entrance, and sometimes even their own laundry. In the real estate market, they’re often advertised as "in-law suites" or "basement apartments."
But are they really a selling point?
Get To Know Us
What Are the Rules Around Granny Flats in Ontario?
Ontario municipalities have been progressively relaxing rules around secondary suites, especially following legislation like the More Homes, More Choice Act (Bill 108) and Bill 23 (More Homes Built Faster Act). These bills encourage densification in existing neighborhoods, aiming to increase rental supply and make more efficient use of developed land.
Most municipalities now require homeowners to meet specific safety, zoning, and building code standards to legalize a secondary unit. For example:
The suite must have a separate entrance.
Ceiling height and natural light (egress windows) are regulated.
Fire safety, soundproofing, and HVAC separation may be required.
One additional parking space is often needed (though this can vary by region).
It’s easier than it used to be to legalize a granny flat, especially in urban areas—but it's still not a one-size-fits-all situation. North Bay, where the Reddit poster is from, may have different zoning or building code interpretations than Toronto or Ottawa.
Does a Granny Suite Help or Hurt a Home Sale?
A recent Reddit post from a homeowner in North Bay raised the question: Does having a fully self-contained basement apartment help or hurt resale? The feedback was, predictably, mixed—and that reflects the real-life complexity of this issue.
Let’s break down some key pros and cons based on the post and wider market insight.
✅ PROS: Why Some Buyers Love Them
Mortgage Qualification Boost
One commenter explained that lenders may factor in rental income from a legal suite when calculating how much a buyer can borrow. This can make it easier for buyers to qualify for a higher-priced home—especially helpful in high-interest-rate environments.Rental Income Potential
Buyers can offset monthly costs with tenant rent, or house family members. In today’s market, where affordability is stretched thin, any chance to generate passive income is appealing.Multi-Generational Living
Some families intentionally look for setups where parents, in-laws, or adult children can live semi-independently. A granny flat provides privacy while staying under one roof.Flexible Usage
If there’s a connecting door, the buyer can choose to keep the suite integrated into the main house, or separate it off again in the future.
❌ CONS: Why It May Turn Some Buyers Off
Wasted Space for Larger Families
Some buyers—particularly those looking for larger homes for children, offices, or hobbies—see a granny suite as lost square footage. Kitchens and laundry rooms take up valuable real estate that could be better used.Maintenance and Upkeep
A second unit often means separate plumbing, appliances, HVAC controls, and more maintenance over time. Not all buyers want that extra layer of responsibility.Legal Uncertainty or Cost to Convert
Not every suite is fully legal. If a suite doesn’t meet code, buyers might need to spend thousands to legalize it or decommission it. Savvy buyers may be wary unless all permits and inspections are up to date.Resale Confusion in Smaller Towns
In places like North Bay, where rental demand may not be as strong as in the GTA, buyers might not see the value in a second suite. One commenter noted they’d remove and discard all second-unit furnishings because they had no intent to rent.
Takeaway for Sellers and Investors
Whether a granny suite helps or hinders a sale depends on a few key variables:
Local demand: In cities or university towns, rental income is king.
Buyer intent: Investors and first-time buyers love suites; large families may not.
Legality and flexibility: The more “turnkey” and legal the suite is, the better.
For investors, a legal, well-maintained secondary suite can boost cap rate and resale value. For homeowners selling in mixed-use areas like North Bay, the key is highlighting flexibility: frame the suite as a “bonus room,” in-law suite, teenager’s retreat, or Airbnb opportunity rather than pigeonholing it as just a rental unit.
How This Ties Into Housing Trends in Ontario
The Ontario government has clearly signaled that more flexible housing types are the future. Secondary suites, garden suites, and even laneway homes are part of the broader movement to densify low-rise neighborhoods. Bill 108 and subsequent housing legislation have removed significant barriers for homeowners who want to build or legalize a second unit.
From a mortgage and investment perspective, this changes the game:
Buyers can qualify for more thanks to income potential.
Investors can house-hack and reduce carrying costs.
Sellers with legal granny flats may attract a new wave of hybrid investor-occupants.
But like the Reddit thread reveals, not all buyers are cut from the same cloth. Some see opportunity; others see an obstacle.
Final Word:
If you're listing a home with a secondary suite in Ontario, know your audience. In the right market, with the right documentation and framing, a granny flat can be a massive value-add. Just make sure to lead with versatility—not just rental potential—and understand that its appeal will differ between urban investors and suburban families.
