Chattels vs. Fixtures in Real Estate: What Buyers Need to Know
When purchasing a home, it’s easy to assume that certain items—like appliances, light fixtures, or even custom-built pieces—are automatically included in the sale.
However, that assumption can lead to costly surprises down the road. This confusion typically arises from the distinction between fixtures and chattels, which plays a crucial role in defining what’s included in or excluded from a real estate transaction.
Understanding these distinctions is essential for buyers, particularly in the context of chattel loans, which can add an additional layer of complexity to the deal. Whether you’re buying in Ontario or elsewhere, it’s important to recognize that not every item in a home is automatically included in the sale just because it appears to belong there.
In this article, we’ll explore common examples of items that might seem like fixtures but are, in fact, considered chattels—and what that means for you as a buyer.
1. Fixtures vs. Chattels: The Basics
Before diving into specific examples, it’s important to understand the difference between fixtures and chattels.
Fixtures are items that are permanently attached to the property. These can include built-in kitchen cabinets, dishwashers, or light fixtures. Items that would cause damage if removed—such as those physically attached to the walls, floors, or ceilings—are typically considered fixtures.
Chattels, on the other hand, are movable items—anything that is not permanently affixed to the property. While this includes common items like furniture and appliances, it can also extend to larger movable property, such as vehicles, mobile homes, or even bicycles.
Here, in this article, we are more concerned with the type of chattels that may seem to be fixtures, but actually isn’t. There are a surprising number of items that fit under this umbrella, which will be mentioned here presently.
2. Common Instances of Fixtures That Could Be Excluded
Kitchen Islands
Take, for example, a custom-built kitchen island. Although it may be showcased as a highlight in the property listing, it doesn’t automatically guarantee it will be included in the sale. This is because, while the island might be a prominent feature, it may not be physically attached to the property—like being fixed to the cabinetry or the floor. As a result, it’s typically classified as chattels, not fixtures.
Buyers should be cautious and make sure to explicitly negotiate for the inclusion of such items if they expect them to be part of the sale. Without clear terms in the offer, the island could be excluded from the transaction.
Appliances
Another commonly disputed item in real estate deals is appliances. A refrigerator, stove, or washer/dryer may seem like they should be part of the deal. However, unless they are built-in or hardwired to the property (like a built-in microwave), they are generally considered chattels. Buyers who assume all appliances are included could face an unpleasant surprise if the seller removes them prior to closing.
Light Fixtures
Light fixtures can also be a gray area. While standard ceiling lights or wall sconces are typically considered fixtures, high-end, decorative light fixtures—such as chandeliers—might be excluded from the sale if not specifically mentioned in the contract. Sellers often take valuable or sentimental items with them, so it’s important to clarify which light fixtures will remain.
Curtains and Rods
Curtains are usually considered chattels, but curtain rods can be tricky. If the rods are custom-installed or part of the room’s architectural design, they may be considered fixtures. Buyers should be careful not to assume that anything attached to the walls is included. It’s essential to clarify whether these items are part of the sale, particularly if they hold personal or aesthetic value.
Bathroom Fixtures
Bathroom fixtures like mirrors and towel racks can also cause confusion. Mirrors mounted to the wall and towel bars that are installed are generally considered fixtures. However, free-standing mirrors or other decorative bathroom items are typically seen as chattels. As always, the key consideration is whether the item is attached to the property in a permanent way.
3. Chattel Loans and Their Role in Real Estate Transactions
In real estate transactions, chattel loans add another layer of complexity. A chattel loan is a type of financing in which personal property (not real estate) is used as collateral. This typically applies when a buyer is financing movable personal property, such as appliances or furniture.
If a buyer takes out a chattel loan to finance an item like a kitchen island, the seller may retain ownership of the item until the loan is paid off. If the item is not explicitly included in the sales agreement, the seller could remove it before closing, creating potential disputes for the buyer.
As a buyer, it’s crucial to understand which items are tied to chattel loans and which are part of the real estate transaction. This clarity will prevent misunderstandings and ensure that items financed through a loan are not incorrectly assumed to be part of the sale.
4. Staging and Its Impact on Buyer Expectations
Home staging can further complicate matters, as it may lead buyers to assume that certain items are part of the sale when they are, in fact, not. Staging involves placing temporary items—such as furniture, rugs, or lighting fixtures—in a home to make it more appealing. While these items help buyers visualize the space, they are often not included in the sale unless specifically stated.
For example, a custom kitchen island or a unique lighting fixture may be staged to show the home at its best. However, unless these items are explicitly mentioned in the contract, they could be considered chattels and excluded from the sale. If the buyer has taken out a chattel loan for such items, they could face further complications with ownership once the sale closes.
Staging can blur the line between what is a fixture and what is a moveable item, so it’s important to ask questions and ensure that any items displayed during the showing are clearly outlined in the offer to purchase.
5. Protecting Yourself as a Buyer: Tips for Navigating Chattel and Fixture Disputes
To avoid surprises, buyers should take proactive steps to ensure that all items they expect to be part of the sale are clearly defined. Here are a few tips to protect yourself:
Get Specific in Your Offer: If you want certain items, such as a kitchen island, appliances, or light fixtures, included in the sale, make sure they are explicitly listed in the offer to purchase. This prevents the seller from excluding them later.
Review the Listing Carefully: Listings may highlight features like a kitchen island or upgraded flooring, but these descriptions may be marketing tools, not definitive statements about what is included in the sale.
Ask Questions: If you’re unsure whether an item is a fixture or chattel, ask the seller’s agent. Clarifying these points early on can prevent misunderstandings.
Consider Legal Advice: If a dispute arises, consulting a real estate lawyer can help ensure your rights are protected, especially if an item has been wrongly excluded from the sale.
Get Professional Advice
Hello, I’m David Pipe. At WealthTrack, we can help you reach your financial goals — book a free 15-minute call with us today to find out how to get started.
Conclusion: Buyer Beware
The distinction between chattels and fixtures is crucial for any real estate transaction. Items like kitchen islands, appliances, and light fixtures may seem like they should be part of the sale, but unless they’re explicitly mentioned in the contract, they could be considered chattels and excluded from the deal.
As a buyer, being specific in your offer, reviewing listings carefully, and asking for clarification on any items that may be staged or promoted is key to avoiding misunderstandings. By paying attention to these details, you can ensure a smoother transaction and avoid unexpected surprises.
